NSW Winter Masters - 29th & 30th July 2000


Report from Wilma Vialle - Director
A group of 41 keen Scrabblers converged on Revesby this past weekend to contest the annual ASPA NSW Winter Masters. Among the throng was a healthy contingent of interstate players on ratings-raiding missions. These included Anne Drew, Dylan Sharma, Olga Visser and Michael Vnuk from Queensland; the travel-anywhere-for-a -Scrabble-tournament Karen Richards from South Australia; Matte Dunn from Tasmania (minus his former Tasmanian tiger hairstyle); and the dynamid duo of Sal and Zina Costanzo, and Saheed Jimoh from Victoria. The tournament also marked John Foley's first tournament since his return to NSW.

Queensland players were first out of the blocks with high-scoring wins: Anne Drew held high game scores in the early rounds with 515 and 570; Michael Vnuk gained an early high word score of 98 for CHASTITY; Olga Visser was also collecting a good collection of scalps. With the Australian Draw system, you can guarantee that after six rounds only one player will be on six wins. On this occasion it was John Foley who went into round 7 undefeated. John lost to Esther Perrins who then occupied top spot until the final (20th) round.

Some of my first-day awards would have to go to Saheed for the most challenges -- I still don't know whether he likes challenging or wanted the exercise -- and to Graeme Lock Lee for margin points squandered -- he lost 80 points and 70 points for time penalty in two of his early games! An interesting coincidence occurred on the challenge computer I operated when two consecutive challenges from different players were REHUNG and REHANGS. There were the usual dramas in end game situations. Dylan Sharma snatched a 2-point victory from Chris May in their game -- Chris played TULIP in an attempt to block an obvious hook play from Dylan, however Dylan was able to play out with a bingo through the I with his rack of AEMRV?? -- his solution appears at the end of this report. John Foley also grabbed a win against Rod Talbot in a similarly dramatic fashion -- Rod was ahead by 91 points but John played out with BANTERED and caught Rod with the J and others, thereby winning the game by 7 points.

At the end of Day 1 and 11 games, Esther Perrins was poised on 10 wins, followed by John Foley on 9 and Paul Cleary and Rod Talbot on 8 games apiece. Sal Costanzo held High Game with 580 and Esther held High Word with 120 for WAXIEST.

Day 2 saw the withdrawal of Ruby Kotwall which meant the elimination of the bye which was good for the players but did require extra work for me as I had to manually manipulate each draw. In round 13, Esther played Michael Vnuk and unknowingly had mis-scored her total by 20 points. Therefore when she played out, she thought she had lost by 17 points but she had won by 3. It illustrates how important it is to check scores throughout the game. The epilogue was another important lesson -- Esther's outplay included a false word which Michael didn't challenge!

Rene Chelton made the most of her first move in one of her games. She opened with MOVE, later played ACUTE, hooking the E to form EMOVE. This was followed by ARENA, creating AT and REMOVE. Having exhausted the front hooks, she then moved to the other end and formed GOR, creating REMOVER and finally played SLEIGHS off that, leaving REMOVERS as the central word on the board!

Dylan Sharma held his breath as he waited for Rod Talbot to make his fifth move in their game. Dylan was praying that Rod would not exchange 5 tiles! The reason? Because Rod had started by exchanging 5 on his first move; his second play was a bonus word; on his third move he exchanged 5; and, yes, played a bonus for his fourth move. Although the pattern stopped there, Rod went on to win that game, helped along by his play of HAZELS for 84 points.

Three "Monarch of the Monolith" games were held (King of the Hill for the unenlightened). Going into the first of these, the top five were Esther on 15, John Foley on 14, Paul on 13, Saheed on 12 and Rod on 12. Wins to Esther, Paul and Rod saw a shuffle of the order to Esther, Paul, John, Rod and Saheed. In this round Paul, John and Saheed scored wins which meant that going into the final round, 3rd, 4th and 5th were already decided: John, Saheed and Rod respectively. First and second would be decided by the final game. Although Esther was one game clear of Paul, his 200 spread win against her in the penultimate game meant that Esther had to draw or win the game to take out the tournament. In a very tight game, Paul emerged victorious to take the trophy and $250 prize money. Generous cash prizes were also awarded to Esther in 2nd, John in 3rd, Saheed in 4th and Rod in 5th. High game was won by Esther with a 636 game -- her victim on that one was John Foley. Saheed won the prize for High Word with SHUNTED for 149 points. Olga Visser received the prize for High Rating Gain for her 136 point boost.

A warm thanks to all participants for the spirit in which the games were played and congratulations for surviving the gruelling 2-day event! Thanks also to all the NSW players who helped in the organisation of the event.

Results after game 20
WINT/MAS -- MASTERS

Rank Player            Wins     Mar
---------------------------------
   1  Paul Cleary         16    1633
   2  Esther Perrins      16    1382
   3  John Foley          15     594
   4  Saheed Jimoh        14    1089
   5  Rod Talbot          14     591
   6  Dylan Sharma        12     334
   7  Chris May           12     233
   8  Joanne Craig        11     902
   9  Bob Jackman         11     643
  10  John Holgate        11     422
  11  Joan Rosenthal      11     193
  12  Michael Vnuk        11     116
  13  John Barker         11      97
  14  Olga Visser         11    -218
  15  Sue Gergelifi       11    -441
  16  Jean McGiffen       11    -449
  17  Matte Dunn          10     238
  18  Karen Richards      10     158
  19  Peter Shaw          10     -39
  20  Sam Greenberg       10    -202
  21  Marie Knight        10    -258
  22  Audrey Newman       10    -319
  23  Graeme Lock Lee     10    -410
  24  Anne Drew            9     398
  25  Hanne Marks          9     182
  26  Sal Costanzo         9     114
  27  Gloria Gallagher     9     -62
  28  Zina Costanzo        9    -168
  29  Betty Foreman        9    -326
  30  Betty Coleman        9    -511
  31  Kris Logan           9    -623
  32  Rene Chelton         8.5  -377
  33  Gary Pollard         8.5  -393
  34  Ros Gibbons          8    -439
  35  Jan Serisier         8    -623
  36  Jeff Chelton         8    -675
  37  Norma Tracey         7    -287
  38  Judy Hay             7    -587
  39  Alison Pollard       7    -686
  40  A Bye                6    -179
  41  Ruby Kotwall         6    -295
  42  Nanette Reynolds     6    -752
HIGH GAME: Esther Perrins    636
HIGH WORD: Saheed Jimoh      149
             "SHUNTING"

Stats for Tournament : WINT/MAS

+--------------------------+-----------+---------+-----------+---------------+
| state     Name           | National  | State   |   Wins    | Rating Points |
|                          | Old  New  | Old New | Exp  Act  | Old Change New|
+--------------------------+-----------+---------+-----------+---------------+
+Section: *MASTERS                     +         +           +               +
+--------------------------------------+---------+-----------+---------------+
| NSW Paul Cleary          |    5    2 |   1   1 | 14.3 16.0 | 1867 +29 1896 |
| NSW Esther Perrins       |   13    5 |   6   2 | 12.0 16.0 | 1784 +81 1865 |
| NSW John Foley           |   12    7 |   5   3 | 12.4 15.0 | 1787 +52 1839 |
| VIC Saheed Jimoh         |    4    6 |   4   4 | 14.9 14.0 | 1877 -14 1863 |
| NSW Rod Talbot           |   15   12 |   7   5 | 12.4 14.0 | 1772 +32 1804 |
| QLD Dylan Sharma         |   87   44 |   4   3 |  7.7 12.0 | 1543 +86 1629 |
| NSW Chris May            |   50   38 |  17  10 | 10.6 12.0 | 1618 +28 1646 |
| NSW Joanne Craig         |   63   49 |  19  15 |  9.4 11.0 | 1581 +34 1615 |
| NSW Bob Jackman          |    6   10 |   2   4 | 14.2 11.0 | 1864 -50 1814 |
| NSW Joan Rosenthal       |   11   23 |   4   8 | 14.3 11.0 | 1798 -66 1732 |
| QLD Michael Vnuk         |  106   70 |   7   5 |  8.2 11.0 | 1513 +56 1569 |
| NSW John Holgate         |    7   13 |   3   6 | 15.4 11.0 | 1854 -69 1785 |
| NSW John Barker          |   34   52 |  10  16 | 14.0 11.0 | 1669 -60 1609 |
| NSW Jean McGiffen        |   27   32 |   9   9 | 12.3 11.0 | 1691 -25 1666 |
| QLD Olga Visser          |  170   89 |  13   6 |  4.9 11.0 | 1400 +136
1536 |
| NSW Sue Gergelifi        |   70   63 |  21  18 | 10.5 11.0 | 1568 +13 1581 |
| NSW Peter Shaw           |   47   42 |  14  12 |  9.4 10.0 | 1620 +12 1632 |
| SA  Karen Richards       |  122   96 |   7   6 |  8.1 10.0 | 1486 +38 1524 |
| TAS Matte Dunn           |   73   78 |   2   3 | 10.5 10.0 | 1564 -10 1554 |
| NSW Audrey Newman        |  204  150 |  53  41 |  6.3 10.0 | 1368 +73 1441 |
| NSW Graeme Lock Lee      |   48   73 |  15  21 | 12.6 10.0 | 1618 -51 1567 |
| NSW Marie Knight         |   45   56 |  12  17 | 11.1 10.0 | 1625 -20 1605 |
| NSW Sam Greenberg        |  229  165 |  57  48 |  5.5 10.0 | 1318 +90 1408 |
| QLD Anne Drew            |   26   51 |   2   4 | 13.0  9.0 | 1692 -80 1612 |
| VIC Sal Costanzo         |   60   60 |  31  31 |  9.1  9.0 | 1592     1592 |
| VIC Zina Costanzo        |  150  137 |  67  62 |  7.9  9.0 | 1439 +22 1461 |
| NSW Gloria Gallagher     |  101  128 |  30  33 | 11.4  9.0 | 1519 -47 1472 |
| NSW Betty Foreman        |  112  109 |  32  27 |  8.9  9.0 | 1504  +1 1505 |
| NSW Hanne Marks          |  183  160 |  49  45 |  7.7  9.0 | 1389 +25 1414 |
| NSW Betty Coleman        |  259  212 |  68  56 |  4.2  9.0 | 1257 +97 1354 |
| NSW Kris Logan           |  144  127 |  41  32 |  7.8  9.0 | 1452 +23 1475 |
| NSW Gary Pollard         |  195  156 |  51  44 |  6.3  8.5 | 1378 +44 1422 |
| NSW Rene Chelton         |  133  132 |  37  35 |  8.5  8.5 | 1467  +1 1468 |
| NSW Jan Serisier         |   78  119 |  24  30 | 11.4  8.0 | 1554 -68 1486 |
| NSW Jeff Chelton         |   96  144 |  28  39 | 11.5  8.0 | 1524 -71 1453 |
| NSW Ros Gibbons          |  168  200 |  46  53 |  9.5  8.0 | 1402 -30 1372 |
| NSW Norma Tracey         |   81  145 |  25  40 | 11.9  7.0 | 1550 -98 1452 |
| NSW Judy Hay             |  242  230 |  61  60 |  4.8  7.0 | 1277 +44 1321 |
| NSW Alison Pollard       |  197  203 |  52  54 |  7.3  7.0 | 1376  -6 1370 |
| NSW Nanette Reynolds     |  231  239 |  58  62 |  6.5  6.0 | 1298 -10 1288 |
| NSW Ruby Kotwall         |   58  164 |  18  47 | 15.2  6.0 | 1594 -185
1409 |
|*NSW A Bye                |    0  216 |   0  57 |  6.0  6.0 | 1350     1350 |
+-------------------------------------+---------+-----------+----------------+

Ruby Kotwall did not play Day 2, and will receive a ratings credit.

Dylan's bonus was MAVERIck.